Homemade Specialty Cookies from Brooklyn

Get your cookie fix with our very own apple pie, chocolate chip, and oatmeal cookies.

Meet the Bakers

Through the strong love of overeating all kinds of foods, Sonny and Shawn created Sonny's Cookie to share homemade cookies with friends and family! Baking played a significant part in adding levity (and a lot of weight) to each day during quarantine lockdown. Inspired by their time participating in the Great Quarantine Bakeoffs with friends, they decide to share some original and classic recipes!

Featured product

Sampler Pack

Regular price
$43.50
Regular price
Sale price
$43.50
Sold Out
Unit price
per 

You asked for it, and now we're answering. This is for the people who want a little variety in their lives. You now have the option to pick between two different cookies or a sample of all! Oh la la!

Featured product

Sonny's Blueberry Pie Cookies - Pack of 10

Regular price
$25.00
Regular price
Sale price
$25.00
Sold Out
Unit price
per 

Yo, listen up here's a story, about a little cookie....a blueberry pie cookie. Our classic buttery, flaky pie cookie crust with a juicy blueberry filling (and a hint of lemon zest). As you know, we love pie and we love cookies. The classic American dessert that you can eat in two bites. I'm blue da ba dee da ba pie. If you've read this far, I hope you appreciate the pun.

Ingredients: Blueberries, Flour, Butter, Sugar, Salt, Cinnamon, Cornstarch, Lemon Zest, Egg for Egg Wash

*Does not contain nuts

Featured product

Shawn's Brown Butter Sea Salt Chocolate Chunk Cookie - Pack of 12

Regular price
$21.50
Regular price
Sale price
$21.50
Sold Out
Unit price
per 

The chunky boys of Sonny's Cookie present the chunkiest cookie yet. Elastic waistband not included. 

Ingredients: Butter, Sugar, Brown Sugar, Vanilla Extract, Eggs, Salt, Baking Soda, Flour, Chocolate Chips

*Does not contain nuts


Featured product

Alex's Lemon Rosemary Crinkle Cookies - Pack of 12

Regular price
$21.50
Regular price
Sale price
$21.50
Sold Out
Unit price
per 

Lemon. Rosemary. Crinkle. That's it, that's the cookie.

 

Ingredients: Lemon, Butter, Sugar, Flour, Vanilla, Baking Soda, Baking Powder, Salt, Powdered Sugar, Rosemary

*Does not contain nuts or any nut products

FAQ

When will my order ship?

Cookies are made to order! We ship all cookies as quickly as we can and will typically send out via UPS Ground (or whatever carrier will get them to you the fastest).

When will my cookies arrive?

Nobody likes stale cookies! Most order will arrive within 1-2 business days of shipping. However, if you live on the west coast, we recommend upgrading to the expedited shipping option for optimal freshness.

Do your cookies contain nuts?

Nope! We are a nut-free bakery.

I have a question about my order, how can I contact you?

Let's chat! Email us at sonnyscookie@gmail.com or message us on Instagram @sonnyscookie, linked below. We love to hear from you!